To Dig or Not to Dig? That is the Question

Few topics in allotment gardening generate as much discussion as how we manage our soil. From traditional digging routines to modern no-dig systems, gardeners continue to explore what works best for productivity, soil health, and long-term sustainability.

At the National Allotment Society, we take a neutral and practical view: there is no single correct method — only approaches that suit different soils, sites, and growers . This article explores the history and science behind digging, including double digging, alongside the principles and evidence behind no-dig gardening.

The Tradition of Single Digging

Single digging has long been the foundation of allotment preparation. Typically carried out in autumn or winter, it involves turning over a spade’s depth of soil and incorporating organic matter such as manure or compost.

Historically, this approach developed as a practical response to:

Heavy or compacted soils needing aeration
Weed control through burial and removal
Preparation of a fine seedbed for spring sowing
Incorporation of bulky organic materials

On many allotment sites, single digging became part of the annual cycle — a way to “reset” beds and prepare for the next growing season.

While effective, it is physically demanding and involves regular disturbance of the soil ecosystem.

Double digging

Double digging is a more intensive method that was once widely promoted in traditional gardening systems. It involves removing the top spade layer of soil and loosening a second layer beneath it, often to a depth of 45–60 cm (18–24 inches), sometimes incorporating organic matter into both layers.

The aim of double digging is to:

Improve deep soil aeration
Break up compacted subsoil layers (“hard pans”)
Encourage deeper root growth for certain crops
Improve drainage in heavy soils

Historically, it was often recommended for establishing new vegetable beds or improving neglected ground.

However, double digging is highly labour-intensive and not always necessary. Modern soil science suggests that while deep cultivation can temporarily improve structure in compacted soils, it also significantly disrupts soil biology and long-established soil layers.

For this reason, it is now more commonly used as an initial soil improvement technique rather than a routine annual practice.

The Rise of No-Dig Gardening

The no-dig movement offers a contrasting approach, based on the principle that:

Soil functions best when its structure and biology are left undisturbed.

Instead of turning the soil, gardeners apply compost or organic matter to the surface, allowing soil organisms to incorporate it naturally over time.

Further guidance from the National Allotment Society can be found here:
www.thenas.org.uk/nodig

Understanding Soil Structure When We Dig

Soil is a complex, living ecosystem containing:

Earthworms and invertebrates
Bacteria and fungi
Organic matter in varying stages of decomposition
Air and water-filled pore spaces
Stable aggregates (“crumb structure”)

When soil is dug or double dug:

Fungal networks (including mycorrhizae) are disrupted
Earthworm burrows are destroyed
Soil layers are mixed, breaking natural stratification
Organic carbon is exposed to oxygen, increasing decomposition rates
Weed seeds can be brought to the surface

Double digging intensifies these effects by disturbing deeper soil layers that are otherwise more stable and less biologically active.

The Science Behind No-Dig

No-dig systems aim to protect and build soil structure rather than rebuild it annually.

By applying compost on the surface:

Soil organisms gradually incorporate organic matter
Worm activity increases natural aeration channels
Fungal networks remain intact
Soil moisture retention improves
Soil carbon is more effectively retained

Over time, this can lead to improved soil structure, better water infiltration, and reduced weed pressure as surface seeds are not repeatedly disturbed.

The Case for Digging

Despite the advantages of no-dig, traditional cultivation still has an important role.

Single digging remains useful for:

Incorporating organic matter into active soil layers
Managing moderately compacted ground
Preparing seedbeds in established plots
Seasonal resetting of beds

Double digging may still be appropriate for:

Establishing new allotment plots on neglected or compacted land
Breaking up severe soil compaction or hard pans
Improving drainage in very heavy clay soils
Deep preparation for long-term vegetable beds

However, it is generally best viewed as a one-off or occasional intervention
, rather than a repeated annual practice.

The Challenges of No-Dig

While increasingly popular, no-dig systems do present practical considerations:

High demand for compost, especially in early years
Time required for soil transition and stabilisation
Need for initial removal of persistent perennial weeds
Slower warming of soil in early spring in some conditions
Dependence on reliable organic matter supply

For these reasons, many gardeners naturally adopt a hybrid approach.

A Balanced Approach

The reality on allotments is that most gardeners do not follow a single strict system.

Instead, they adapt:

Digging new or problematic areas
Using no-dig principles on established beds
Occasionally double digging where deep improvement is needed
Adjusting methods based on soil type, crops, and time available

This flexible approach often produces the best long-term results.

The debate over “to dig or not to dig” — and whether to double dig — is less about choosing a winner and more about understanding context.

Digging offers immediate, practical soil improvement and control
Double digging provides deep, structural change in specific situations
No-dig focuses on long-term soil health and ecosystem stability

All can be valid tools in the allotment gardener’s toolkit.

Join The National Allotment Society

Become a National Allotment Society member and help to preserve and protect allotments for future generations.
You'll also gain a range of benefits including free liability insurance, initial legal support, expert advice and much more.

Join Now

Non Member Newsletter Signup

National Society of Allotment & Leisure Gardeners Ltd
Registered in 1930 under the Industrial & Provident Societies Acts no. 11144R
VAT No. 1212930 14
Patron His Majesty King Charles III